A Joyful Evening Cut Short By A Fateful Moment of Violence
On the evening of May 21, 2025, Sarah Milgrim, a 26-year-old American from Kansas working at the Israeli Embassy, was radiant with hope and purpose as she attended an event at the Capital Jewish Museum in Washington, D.C. Alongside her boyfriend and colleague, Yaron Lischinsky, Sarah was immersed in an American Jewish Committee gathering focused on bridge-building in the Middle East, a cause close to her heart given her work with young Israelis and Palestinians. Friends later recalled her vibrant presence, her red hair lighting up the room as she laughed and mingled, unaware that Yaron had recently purchased an engagement ring, planning to propose during an upcoming trip to Jerusalem. The event, aimed at fostering humanitarian aid for Gaza, embodied Sarah’s commitment to peace and her Jewish identity, which she had proudly embraced since her college days at the University of Kansas. As she and Yaron stepped out onto the quiet street around 9 p.m., their evening of connection and optimism was about to be shattered.
As Sarah and Yaron walked away from the museum, the night air was calm, with two other young American women from the embassy nearby, unharmed in what would soon unfold. Unbeknownst to them, Elias Rodriguez, a 31-year-old Chicago man, was approaching, driven by a radicalized hatred linked to his vocal support for the Palestinian cause. According to FBI accounts, Rodriguez passed the couple before turning back, drawing a firearm, and shooting them in the back in a cold, calculated act. Sarah, who had once expressed fears about rising antisemitism in 2017, saying, “I worry about going to my synagogue,” fell alongside Yaron, both struck fatally. Rodriguez’s chilling words, “I did it for Palestine, I did it for Gaza,” echoed as he was apprehended, chanting “Free Palestine” while police secured the scene. The suddenness of the attack left no time for Sarah to react, her last moments marked by the abrupt theft of a life dedicated to understanding and dialogue.
The aftermath of Sarah’s murder sent shockwaves through Washington and beyond, with the Jewish community in her hometown of Overland Park, Kansas, gathering in grief at a vigil on May 22. Hundreds mourned Sarah, described by friend Amanda Birger as someone who “made me want to be more Jewish” through her joyful, faithful life. The tragedy, labeled an antisemitic hate crime and act of terrorism by authorities, underscored the fears Sarah had voiced years earlier about Jewish safety. Her death, alongside Yaron’s, was not random, as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu noted, but a targeted act fueled by what he called “wild incitement” against Jews. As Misaskim volunteers collected remains from the bloodied sidewalk and Yaron’s body was returned to Israel, Sarah’s legacy as a kind, smart advocate for peace endured. Her final moments, though stolen by a gunman’s hatred, could not erase the light she brought to those who knew her, nor the urgent call her death amplified to confront antisemitism and extremism.
