California election officials have declined to segregate ballots associated with more than twenty thousand individuals identified by the Department of Homeland Security as likely noncitizens. That refusal is not a technical quibble over data reliability or administrative capacity. It is a deliberate choice to treat federal statutes that criminalize noncitizen participation in federal elections as optional rather than binding. The Supremacy Clause does not yield to state preference on the question of who may cast a ballot for Congress or the President; yet California has proceeded on the premise that its own processes take precedence once ballots are in hand.

The Supreme Court’s summary denial of the Justice Department’s emergency application leaves that premise intact for the duration of the current contest. The Court offered no explanation and recorded no dissents, consistent with its ordinary practice on eve-of-election applications under the Purcell principle. The practical consequence is that ballots the federal government contends were cast by ineligible voters will be tabulated and commingled with lawful votes. Once that occurs, the distinction becomes practically unrecoverable, and any subsequent finding of illegality can affect only the margins of future accountability rather than the outcome of this election.

The Department of Justice has already filed suit and has publicly stated that noncitizen voting in federal elections is a crime it intends to prosecute. Officials have been placed on formal notice that facilitating or ignoring such votes may expose them to legal consequence. There is therefore no element of surprise in what follows. Enforcement of the statute is the ordinary course the Department has announced; the only novelty is that California’s refusal, and the Court’s decision not to interrupt it, have made the necessity of that enforcement plain to every observer.

Additional ADNN Articles: 

Ninth Circuit Lets California Run Its Own Federal Election Rules
Trump’s DOJ Files Lawsuits to Secure Midterm Ballot Integrity
No Democrat State Checks Citizenship on Its Voter Rolls
Dhillon’s DOJ Demands States Bar Noncitizens from Federal Ballots